Wednesday, September 17, 2025

Book Review: He Falls First

By Melissa Smoot

Ryder Colburn has his hands full running the family business and caring for the ailing father who’s a virtual stranger from the cold, heavy-handed man he used to be. He’s got zero free time for hobbies or women. Or so he thinks until one walks into his life… and the path of an oncoming car.

Ryder doesn’t mind playing the hero for the skittish, scarred chef Penny. Maybe it’s the secrets in her eyes or the scar on her chin. Whatever the reason, he’s compelled to get closer.

Penny’s learned her lesson and now she’s paying the price. That’s why she’s sharing a dilapidated house in a tiny California town with her feisty grandmother and tween brother living off the leftovers from her catering job. It’s a far cry from her dream life. But who needs dreams… or love… or sex when there’s amateur plumbing projects to tackle and breakfast casseroles to bake?

One thing’s for sure, she’s never falling in love again. Not even with the sexy, snarky contractor who keeps testing the walls she’s built. (Synopsis courtesy of Amazon.)

Jill Shalvis delivers another emotionally resonant and charming romance in He Falls First, the inaugural entry in her new Colburn Brothers series. Known for her signature blend of humor, heart, and small-town warmth, Shalvis gives us a story that is both tender and engaging, with characters who feel real and relatable. 

The town of Star Falls is vividly portrayed, with quirky side characters and cozy details that enhance the small-town charm. Our two main characters, Ryder and Penny, have both suffered past traumas and have a hard time opening their hearts or breaking down the wall they built up. Throughout the story, we start to see the trust that is being built between them. Although there are some very serious and potentially triggering topics in this book, it felt very thoughtfully written and safe. There were also many joyful and silly aspects to this story.

I found myself laughing out loud many times throughout the story. From the brothers’ sarcasm and witty banter to the resident Parrot with his nonstop outbursts, this was such a fun read. If you are a Jill Shalvis fan (or even if this is your first time reading one of her books), you will love He Falls First.

(Content warnings at the bottom of this post.)

Thanks to Sourcebooks for the book in exchange for an honest review.

More by Jill Shalvis:
Free Falling (2nd book in the Colburn Brothers series)
Lost and Found Sisters
The Family You Make

Enjoyed this post? Never miss out on future posts by following us.

Listen to this book on Speechify!

*


*


*


*


*


*

CW: Child abuse and domestic violence are discussed. Death of family member (when character was younger).

No comments: